Defense claims unlawful interrogation as Daniel Penny demonstrates chokehold in court over controversial subway incident

Daniel Penny has demonstrated to an NYPD detective how he restrained Jordan Neely in a chokehold, a moment captured in a recorded interrogation video that has since garnered significant attention.

Defense attorneys Thomas Kenniff and Steven Raiserv argued for the suppression of this demonstration and other statements made by Penny, claiming that their client was questioned unlawfully without being informed of his right against self-incrimination.

The hearing unfolded with an all-day exploration of the incident, featuring testimonies from a detective and three officers who detailed the investigation’s progression.

Also Read: Bronx Borough Office partners GrowNYC to enhance food access for local residents.

Body-camera footage played during the hearing depicted Penny standing next to Neely’s prone body, identifying himself as the individual who had restrained him. “He was threatening everybody,” Penny stated on the footage, making a headlock gesture with his arms. “I took him out.”

Witness accounts revealed that Neely boarded the subway train around 2:30 p.m. on May 1, 2023, where he reportedly threw his jacket on the floor and demanded a Sprite or ginger ale. Police recordings reveal unnamed witnesses describing Neely as “erratic” and “threatening.”

One woman stated, “He was scaring the living daylights out of everybody. It seemed like he intended to do something.” Another witness added, “Penny saved the train.”

Throughout the proceedings, Penny, dressed in a baseball cap and tan jacket over a hoodie, remained behind the first responders, offering his driver’s license to one officer.

Kenniff questioned the responding officers about whether Penny was free to leave or if he was being detained, a critical point for the admissibility of his statements. The lawyer highlighted that all other witnesses were ordered off the train except for Penny. At one moment, when he attempted to exit the subway car, an officer touched his chest to stop him, instructing him to stay.

Kenniff contended that Penny felt compelled to share details with police due to the “police-dominated atmosphere.” In the interrogation room, the detective attempted to connect with Penny by discussing their shared U.S. Marine Corps service.

Penny described Neely as “a crackhead,” emphasizing that he was attempting to protect women and children on the train. “He was getting in people’s faces,” Penny remarked in the video. “He was moving from person to person. I’m not trying to kill the guy.”

When asked to demonstrate his actions, Penny stood behind the investigator, wrapping his arm around the detective’s neck to illustrate the chokehold he had applied, a technique he claimed to have learned during military training.

Penny explained that he held Neely until police arrived, stating, “I’m still holding him because he’s squirming around, I’m like, ‘Get the cops, get the cops.’ It seemed like he’d calmed down and then he’d get another burst of energy.” This point is critical, as it may clarify why Penny did not release Neely even after he appeared to stop moving.

Prosecutors allege that Penny maintained the chokehold for six minutes, continuing even after Neely ceased to struggle.

A passenger’s video from the incident captures the lengthy struggle on the subway floor, raising significant concerns about the appropriateness of Penny’s actions. As the case unfolds, the implications of this incident continue to resonate within the community and the legal system.

  • Related Posts

    Senator Sanders Condemns U.S. Funding of Israel’s War in Gaza, Cites Death of Over 18,000 Children

    U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders has delivered a searing critique of American support for Israel’s ongoing military campaign in Gaza, accusing Washington of bankrolling war crimes that have left tens of…

    Continue reading
    Five Killed, Including Police Officer, in Manhattan Skyscraper Mass Shooting

    Chaos erupted in the heart of Manhattan Monday evening as a heavily armed gunman stormed a high-rise office building on Park Avenue, killing four people — including a New York…

    Continue reading

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    Community Op-Ed: Seasons change, but our priorities remain the same: Building record amounts of housing to make New York City more affordable

    Community Op-Ed: Seasons change, but our priorities remain the same: Building record amounts of housing to make New York City more affordable

    Bronx Residents Blast Councilmembers Over Bainbridge and Just Home Votes, Accuse Betrayal as Councilwoman Defends Position

    Bronx Residents Blast Councilmembers Over Bainbridge and Just Home Votes, Accuse Betrayal as Councilwoman Defends Position

    Community Op-Ed: The Adams Administration’s Report Card: A City Government That Works for All New Yorkers

    Community Op-Ed: The Adams Administration’s Report Card: A City Government That Works for All New Yorkers

    Gates Foundation Pledges $912 Million to Global Fund

    Gates Foundation Pledges $912 Million to Global Fund

    Mayor Adams Announces Automatic Rebates for Homeowners Buying NYC Bins

    Mayor Adams Announces Automatic Rebates for Homeowners Buying NYC Bins

    Mayor Adams Expands Trash Containerization to Brooklyn Community District 2

    Mayor Adams Expands Trash Containerization to Brooklyn Community District 2